Learn when cash prices with discount programs can be cheaper than using your Medicare coverage
Here's what most Medicare Advantage members don't know: You can choose to pay cash with discount programs like GoodRx instead of using your Medicare coverage when it saves you money. This is completely legal and sometimes results in significant savings.
Many Medicare Advantage plans have high copays for certain medications, especially in the deductible phase or for non-preferred drugs. In these cases, using a discount program might cost less than your Medicare copay.
Here are common scenarios where paying cash with GoodRx might be cheaper than using your Medicare Advantage coverage:
Scenario | Medicare Advantage Cost | GoodRx Cash Price | Best Choice |
---|---|---|---|
Generic in Deductible Phase Lisinopril 10mg (30 tablets) |
$45 (full cost until deductible met) | $8 with GoodRx | Use GoodRx |
Non-Preferred Brand Drug Nexium 40mg (30 capsules) |
$85 copay (Tier 3) | $45 with GoodRx | Use GoodRx |
Specialty Medication High-cost injection |
$200 copay (Tier 4) | $125 with manufacturer coupon | Use Manufacturer Program |
Preferred Generic Metformin 500mg (90 tablets) |
$5 copay | $15 with GoodRx | Use Medicare |
Example 1: Sarah's Diabetes Medications
Sarah has Medicare Advantage with a $400 deductible. In January, her metformin costs $45 through Medicare (deductible phase) but only $8 with GoodRx. She saves $37 by using GoodRx for the first few months until her deductible is met.
Example 2: Robert's Heart Medication
Robert's Eliquis has a $75 copay on his Medicare plan (Tier 3). With a manufacturer coupon, he pays only $10. He saves $65 per month by not using his Medicare coverage for this medication.
Example 3: Maria's Generic Prescriptions
Maria's plan covers most generics for $5 copays. GoodRx prices are typically $10-15 for the same medications. She uses her Medicare coverage because it's consistently cheaper.
As a licensed insurance professional, I can help you analyze your specific medications and Medicare plan to create a personalized cost-saving strategy that maximizes your savings year-round.